When the California Master Plan for Higher Education unfolded
in 1960, the framers intended that student access to college would be
a cornerstone of its success. It specifically targeted community colleges
as a mechanism for dramatically changing lives. And this was particularly
true for minorities and women who were traditionally disenfranchised.
Indeed, it was a visionary approach to making certain that all Californians
would have an opportunity to enroll and obtain postsecondary education
if they were interested and could profit from doing so.
For over 40 years, this philosophical and practical value
has guided the Community College movement to the point of being viewed
as one of the most important inventions of higher education in the 20th
Century. Hundreds of thousands of individuals have profited from a California
community college education and now serve in influential positions throughout
the world. It particularly gave those with the least amount of hope
and opportunity the tools to achieve their educational goals. Hartnell
College, one of the 108 Community Colleges in the State and among the
eight oldest, has been a ray of sunshine for the residents of the Salinas
Valley and Monterey County.
Nevertheless, a dark cloud has been forming across the
State and it threatens a serious downpour on those who most need educational
and occupational training. Specifically, it will shut tight the door
to tens of thousands of students over the next ten years, thus dooming
them to an uncertain economic future, and California with a less than
prepared citizenry.
Recent research uncovered the unusually low college participation
rate of adult Californians, particularly in the City of Salinas, and
serves only as an indicator of what is to come. Arguably, such a claim
is evident in a recent report entitled "California's Investment in Public
Education: A Look at the Past Decades," by Tom Nussbaum, State Chancellor
for California Community Colleges. He has rightly stated, "California
Community Colleges have become less accessible over time and the state
is now entering a period during which it will begin to reduce enrollments,
rather than address the demand to serve 600,000 additional students
by the year 2010." Commonly referred to as Tidal Wave II, these students
are enrolling now and will continue to do so for the next ten years
and beyond.
More evidence is available from Hartnell College, a federally
designated Hispanic Service Institution located in Salinas, California,
and from the other 108 Community Colleges across the State of California.
For example, in Fall and Spring 2003, the college trimmed its course
offerings by 15-20% in response to a state mandate: froze teacher hiring;
reduced enrollment in academic programs; consolidated management positions;
and is now in the process of gearing up for the possibility of a 2004
mid-year correction. Moreover, Fall 2003 offerings are down 20-25%.
Specifically for Fall 2003, we are offering 200 plus fewer sections
compared to Fall 2002. The outcome has resulted in denial of access
to more than 2,000 students. I would stated that our sister colleges--Cabrillo
College, Monterey Peninsula and Gavilan College have similar stories
to tell. Combined, it is speculated that this year, more than 10,000
interested students were denied access in some form or another and that
may be the beginning of a trend.
The convergence of state budget woes, abrupt increases
in student fees, reduced funding or shifting of funding priorities,
complex formulas that seem to punish creativity rather than reward it,
and confused state policy, all have made it virtually impossible for
community colleges to make good on the state's promise in the Master
Plan for Higher Education, i.e., access to all. It is troubling to me
that this denial of access is occurring at a time when the traditionally
disenfranchised and immigrant students are showing more interest in
attaining a higher degree of learning and training. It is equally disturbing
when you consider the fact that the State of California is an ethnic
minority state, with a majority of its population comprised of traditionally
ethnic minority populations--African Americans, Hispanics, Asians, and
females.
Community colleges deserve more serious attention. They
are not the junior college many people fondly remember. Instead, they
are comprehensive institutions with programs and services that meet
the needs of a ever-growing complex and demanding student body and community.
As an example of this, Hartnell College serves nearly 10,500 students.
More than half are Latinos, followed by a healthy mixture of Whites,
African Americans, Native Americans, Asians, and, of course, international
students. Agriculture, Nursing, Engineering, Media Technology, English,
Science and Math and a rigorous athletics program reflect just a sampling
of its offerings. It contributes mightily to the workforce of the community.
Across the State of California, community colleges serve
more than a million plus students, compared to the combined student
populations of all the UCs, and CSUs totaling nearly 800,000. Community
colleges are major providers of the workforce needed in industry at
the local, state, national and increasingly the international levels.
They are reservoirs for CSU and UC junior enrollments and tend to be
on par or better than their age cohorts entering the university as freshmen.
They are the training center for industry leaders seeking young qualified
talent. And as President George Bush pointed out in his news conference
July 30, 2003, "Community colleges are adaptable, with curriculum that
is easy to change; they are everywhere." And while the President went
on to say they are accessible, he is not fully cognizant of the challenges
facing California Community Colleges.
Hartnell Community College has served the Salinas Valley
for more than eight-years and along with the other 108 community colleges,
these are the "little engines that could." They have paved the way for
many citizens to access learning and training opportunities to afford
them a better life. They have been beacons of light for hundreds of
thousands of citizens. However, that light is slowly fading, and when
it has totally faded access for students will be denied. And we will
be asked, what happened to our chance? And why?
________________
Edward J. Valeau is entering
his 9th year as the Superintendent/President of Hartnell Community College
in Salinas, California. He is also the Chair of the American Association
of Community College Legislative and Policy Commission.